Ulysses S. Grant is only tangentially related to the story I tell in “You Need a Schoolhouse.” In 1874 Grant was president — a national hero and, arguably, the most famous man in America – and he had come to Springfield, Illinois for the festivities surrounding the dedication of a memorial to Abraham Lincoln at his grave there. Rosenwald was 12, growing up in a house across the street from the home that had been the Lincolns’, and he made $2.50 peddling a pamphlet about the monument in the crowd that day. Years later he remembered seeing the president in his carriage and noticing that he wore yellow kid gloves. In my book I say that young Julius was picking up “the eye of a clothier and the ways of a salesman.”
But a new book tells another, much more complex story that relates Grant to Jews. Grant has often been charged with being an anti-semite for the executive order he issued in 1862 expelling Jews from the war zone under his jurisdiction. Like the charge that he was a hopeless alcoholic, the claim has enough basis in fact to be believable. But in a new book Jonathan Sarna, a history professor at Brandeis Universitiy, tells the full story of the order — hastily given, almost immediately rescinded by Lincoln, and later sincerely and convincingly repudiated by Grant who became known as a friend to Jews both in this country and abroad. A local detail I appreciated was that on June 9, 1876, Grant became the first American president to attend a synagogue dedication when he and his oldest son went to ceremonies at Adas Israel here in Washington and impressed their hosts by staying for the whole three hours. I haven’t read the book (though I did get it for Christmas) but there is a good summary of it in this very interesting review by Jeff Jacoby.
http://www.jeffjacoby.com/11675/when-general-grant-expelled-the-jews
I’ve been thinking about Jews and the Civil War for the past few days after seeing “The Whipping Man,” a play by Matthew Lopez that — by coincidence — is being performed this spring at the Washington Jewish Community Center’s Theater J, where I saw it, and also at Baltimore’s Centerstage. The action takes place at a ruined home in Richmond just a few days after the city fell to the Union army and Lee had surrendered. Caleb, the son of the family, returns from war, horribly injured, to find the place empty, everyone having fled elsewhere for safety except for Simon, the family’s elderly slave who is caring for the house despite the fact that, as he quickly reminds Caleb, he is now free. They are soon joined by John, another slave, a cocky young man who years before had been Caleb’s childhood playmate.
That the family is Jewish is established right from the start. That the slaves, too , consider themselves Jews emerges as Simon realizes that it is Passover and decides they must have a Seder. His preparations are interrupted by the shocking news of Lincoln’s assassination yet the seder takes place anyway. Sitting in a ransacked house, with the future anything but clear, and despite the fact that he is not the traditional youngest but the oldest of them, Simon insists on asking the question, “Why is this night different from all other nights?” As the ceremony goes on and the story of the Exodus unfolds, he sings, not a Jewish song but the old spiritual about Moses in Egypt with the powerful refrain, “Let my people go.” By the end of the service the story has been retold and newly savored but devastating personal truths have also been revealed. Simon has left the house and Caleb and John sit together yet separately, staring silently into space as if facing into the hard realities of the years to come.
The program notes stay that at the time of the Civil War there were about 25,000 Jews in the South and that about 40% of those families owned slaves. 3,000 Jewish soldiers fought for the Confederacy, 7,000 served on the Union side. One of them, shortly before he was killed in battle, wrote a letter to his wife that is quoted in the program. His post in Louisiana had allowed him to observe the way things were in the South. “Slavery is gone up,” he wrote, “whether the War ends today or in a year and there is no use crying over it, it has been an awful institutuion…Now understand me when I saw I am a strong abolitionist I mean that I am not so for party purposes but for humanity sake only, out of my own conviction, for the best interest of the white man in the south and the black man anywheres.”
Just before writing this I took a walk with David and our dog, Nico, past the Capitol building, dow
n to the Mall. It is a gorgeous day here in Washington and we stopped to look at the ducklings on the reflecting pool, to snap pictures for a family celebrating with a graduate in cap and gown, and then to look at the statue at the base of the Capitol. It’s my favorite of DC’s many equestrian males — General Grant, with a brimmed hat and a cloak that looks like it is being whipped by a cold wind, an angle to his head that is both weary and determined. The statue is flanked by bronze horses and soldiers on caissons where, as little boys, my sons used to like to play. It’s a powerful reminder not just of the excruciating pain of all war but of the particular agony of the war that divided our country and of the very long and painful road we have traveled since then.















